We run a small e-commerce store in Valencia selling handmade leather bags and custom travel accessories. Four months ago, we hired an SEO specialist for 650 Euros a month; so far, 2,600 Euros has left our pocket. We're told technical foundation issues were cleaned up, category descriptions rewritten, and two informative guide blog posts published each week.
Looking at the dashboards, there seems to be a tiny bump in Google impressions, but daily organic visitors never exceed 15 people. Worst of all, we haven't made a single sale through organic search traffic in these entire 4 months. We cut down our paid ad budget to fund this, so our company's cash flow is taking a real hit.
Where are we realistically supposed to be at this stage? Should I wait a few more months and keep paying 650 Euros, or call this an obvious failure and pull the plug? How do I even tell if things are moving in the right direction without any sales?