Tried an SEO text generator — do these texts actually rank, or are they just filler, and how do I check?

We tried the exact same route with our 2,400-part technical site. Generated auto-descriptions for 600 products, zero traffic bump over 4 months. Then we picked the 40 most-searched products and had someone write 150 words by hand using real craftsman terminology; traffic to those 40 products nearly quadrupled within two months.

Are you seeing 'Crawled - currently not indexed' warnings for those 350 pages in Search Console? When Google catches automated copy repeating itself, it might just skip indexing them altogether. That's the very first place you should check.

You can't write all of them manually, it's just not realistic. Do this instead: write detailed copy for the top 50 products by hand. For the rest of the auto-generated texts, delete the first two paragraphs and just leave 3-4 bullet points of concrete info under 'Applications' and 'Package Contents'. Trim the fluff.

AI copywriters generate absolute garbage for technical hardware. Instead of critical data like steel grade or torque specs, they churn out generic marketing cliches like 'make your job easier with this amazing screwdriver'. A German tradesman will abandon cart the second he reads that.

totally normal for bounce rates to spike nobody shopping for technical screws wants to read an essay. put the dimensions front and center push the text below the table minimize its prominence.

Run these 3 tests to spot if automated text is just fluff: 1) Strip out the brand and product name; if the text still works for 20 other products, it's trash. 2) Does it state which tools the part is compatible with? 3) Does it take over a minute to read while offering zero technical data?

We jumped in with the exact same excitement and it was a complete letdown. Turns out word count doesn't mean a thing. The customer only has one question: will this part fit my machine? The AI tool doesn't know that so it just fills the page with nonsense.

You're completely missing search intent. People looking for technical products aren't looking for a story, they're verifying specs. Instead of asking the generator for generic prose, give it rigid prompts to turn the data points from your table into clean, scannable micro-copy.

if I understood correctly youre saying: Map listings bring more business than blog posts for most local businesses.

hasty decisions become decisions you have to fix six months later. if I were you, I'd go this route.

I agree.

we need to make a distinction here. honestly ranking is the result, search inetnt is the input but look at intent first.

if you have questions write them; I'll answer as best I can.

Same here.

The answer above hits the nail on the head. When you try to change everything at once, nothing settles.

Updating an existing page yields faster results than creating a new one.

I'd appreciate it if you shared the outcome. Processes without records never improve, because you don't know what to fix.

Proven by experience.

Just a heads-up. Internal linking is the cheapest and most neglected task.

Mistakes made on the seo text generator side are usually reversible but expensive. Hope this helps.

We experienced almost the exact same thing last year. When you try to change everything at once, nothing settles.

I'm a small business, let me explain from my side. Updating an existing page yields faster results than creating a new one.

Good luck with that.

Just a heads-up. If you get three different answers on a topic, the question was asked wrong.

Of course, it varies if your situation is different.