We serve on the homeowners association (HOA) board of a 42-unit community in New Jersey. Our annual budget for dues and common area maintenance is around 110,000 dollars. Up until now, all dues records, maintenance requests, and meeting minutes were kept in files on our former manager's personal computer; when they moved out, tracking down all the records took us two months.
Two of the three board members want to switch to a free property management software they found online to keep costs at zero. However, we have a major disagreement over who will handle the initial setup, who will keep the system updated, and most importantly, who actually owns the residents' personal IDs, license plates, and payment records. None of us on the board are developers or sysadmins.
How can an all-volunteer board with no tech background split these responsibilities fairly? If we go with free software, what precautions should we take so records don't vanish when the board turns over, and so legal liability doesn't fall on just one person?